Issue 45 / 23 November 2015

DOCTORS and medical students who use social media are reminded to keep postings professional after a survey of medical students found about one in three had posted unprofessional content on social media.
 
The voluntary survey of 880 medical students, published online by the MJA today, found that 34.7% of respondents (306) self-reported posting unprofessional conduct on social media. (1)
 
The most common depiction reported was of intoxication (301 students, 34.2%), as well as use of illegal drugs (14 students, 1.6%). Posting of patient information was reported by 14 students.
 
“The use of social media by the surveyed cohort was almost universal, and unprofessional behaviours on social media were exhibited by a significant proportion of medical students, despite widespread awareness of guidelines about professionalism”, the authors wrote.
 
The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP) issued social media guidelines earlier this year and the AMA is in the process of updating its 2010 social media guidelines, with the revised version expected to be released early next year. (2), (3)
 
Queensland GP Dr Edwin Kruys, who hosts the popular general practice blog Doctor’s bag, said the findings should fuel discussion about how medical students and the wider medical profession engaged with social media. (4)
 
“It’s a new medium, and we have to keep the discussion going and help each other to improve our online presence”, said Dr Kruys, who is also chair of the Queensland faculty of the RACGP.
 
Dr Kruys said the new RACGP social media guidelines were developed in conjunction with medical defence organisations and provided guidance on how to engage on the various social media platforms, as well as cautions about how not to use social media.
 
He said while there were many pitfalls in using social media, such platforms were also powerful tools that could be used to engage with colleagues, patients and policymakers.
 
“We’d like to make [medical students] aware of the power of social media and how they can use it in a really good way as students, but also later down the track as doctors”, Dr Kruys said.
 
The researchers noted that factors associated with the posting of unprofessional conduct by students included evidence of alcohol misuse and racist content, and plans to change their profile after graduating.
 
They wrote that despite widespread dissemination and awareness of guidelines among medical students, this appeared to have little impact on their behaviour. 
 
“There is a distinction between disseminating guidelines and formally integrating social media instruction into medical curricula. Senior clinicians and teachers who have not used social media may … be ill equipped for teaching their juniors about professionalism in a social media context”, they wrote, saying medical educators should consider approaches beyond simply providing students with guidelines or policies. 
 
“Students should be regularly prompted to reflect on their activities, to evaluate their online behaviours, and to temper them if appropriate”, they wrote.
 
Dr Kruys said it was important for medical students to look to professional role models for guidance on making the most of social media.
 
He said he used the “elevator test” to determine whether content was suitable to publish on his blog. “If I feel that I would be embarrassing myself or other people by saying it out loud in an elevator, then I wouldn’t post it”, he said, adding that he also sought legal advice when establishing his blog. 
 
Dr Kruys said medical defence organisations could also advise doctors on what was appropriate to post on social media. 
 
Dr Christopher Ryan, clinical associate professor of psychiatry at the University of Sydney’s Centre for Values, Ethics and the Law in Medicine, said the most striking aspect of the MJA research findings was the low percentage of students who had posted unprofessional content online.
 
“These are quite young people who would have had their Facebook pages presumably through their high school years. The major posts that the authors were concerned about were evidence of intoxication with alcohol, and I thought it was quite impressive that only 30% of [these students] had such posts”, Dr Ryan said.
 
Medical students were a “relatively sensible population”, which was borne out by the fact that only 1.6% had posted content depicting illegal drug use, which would include cannabis, said Dr Ryan, who was a coauthor on research published last year that found doctors could benefit from additional training in using social media. (5)
 
He agreed that also providing medical students with formal support to negotiate these issues would be “sensible”. 
 
 
 
(Photo: PathDoc / shutterstock)
 
A podcast with Dr Jake Barlow, coauthor of the MJA research, is available and also as a video.
 

Poll

Should medical schools be responsible for educating students about social media?
  • Yes – on the risks and benefits (71%, 105 Votes)
  • No – it’s just common sense (17%, 25 Votes)
  • Maybe – could be included in ethics (12%, 17 Votes)

Total Voters: 147

Loading ... Loading ...

5 thoughts on “Students behaving badly

  1. Henry Woo says:

    Virtually all of our medical students and specialty trainees are on social media.  The majority of users have ‘grown up’ with SoMe (that’s short for social media for my many colleagues who have no idea) in a completely guideline and mentorship free zone.  This is changing as professional organisations are not only becoming engaged with social media but are also publishing guidelines on appropriate behaviour on social media.  Many senior doctors reject SoMe in the same way that many rejected fax machines and email when they were first introduced – or to exagerate, like those who opposed the introduction of motor vehicles over horse powered transport.  Rather than be taken kicking and screaming into the world of social media, senior doctors should take up the responsibility to understand this space and to offer guidance in the same way that is done about IRL (in real life) professional behaviour. Their patients and students/trainees are there and they need to be there as well.

  2. Anthony Wright says:

    It is an interesting question as to whether or not the medical students are “relatively sensible”, or representative of their peers.  In the AFL, another non-typical cohort, there were only 16 failed illicit drugs tests in 2013, from over 1000 random tests.  There is probably about 1 “Facebook outing” of illicit drug use of an AFL player a year (of 720 players and rookies).  It would seem that the medical student cohort are higher than that.  Around 10% of persons 14 and over admit to illicit drug use in the previous 12 months according to 2013 data, so if 1:10 place that on social media that would make the medical student cohort pretty average…

  3. Christine Troy says:

    Maybe the medical board could offer individual counselling to those who “out” themselves on social media wrt drug use rather than move it underground with rules of professionalism.

    The use of social media regarding testimonials, I feel, also needs review.  As a consumer, I find that the subspecialties and interests of each doctor would be useful to know. As a referring doctor, I would find it useful to be able to Google which limbs an orthopaedic surgeon prefers to work on, or whether a psychiatrist sees children or not, as some examples. As a doctor, I would like my patients to know that I am caring, thorough and a safe practitioner. 

     

     

  4. University of Queensland - Central Library says:

    I use social media as an additional way in which to communicate with medical students I teach. While the university has course websites, when new information comes to light that I think they need for their greater elucidation, I post it to my Twitter account. In doing so I also model appropriate professional demeanour with regard to social media use. It’s one way to teach the “social curriculum”. I just adapt the general courtesies of everyday life to my social media use and also add emerging content that I think students need to know. On balance, social media is useful when teaching a large group of students.

  5. Sue Ieraci says:

    I favour medical schools teaching professional behaviour in general. Medical graduates arent just receiving a degree – almost 100% of them will enter registered medical practice. That doesn’t mean that student years have to be staid – but it does mean that potential doctors need to learn some basic rules for public exposure, internet privacy and protection of one’s on-line reputation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.