Log in with your email address username.

×

Important notice

doctorportal Learning is on the move as we will be launching a new website very shortly. If you would like to sign up to dp Learning now to register for CPD learning or to use our CPD tracker, please email support@doctorportal.com.au so we can assist you. If you are already signed up to doctorportal Learning, your login will work in the new site so you can continue to enrol for learning, complete an online module, or access your CPD tracker report.

To access and/or sign up for other resources such as Jobs Board, Bookshop or InSight+, please go to www.mja.com.au, or click the relevant menu item and you will be redirected.

All other doctorportal services, such as Find A Doctor, are no longer available.

Sentinel lymph node biopsy for melanoma: an important risk-stratification tool

- Featured Image

To the Editor: The article by Gyorki and Henderson1 is misleading and inaccurate. The stated primary outcome of the Multicenter Selective Lymphadenectomy Trial-1 (MSLT-1) was:

To determine whether wide excision of the primary with intraoperative lymphatic mapping (LM) followed by selective lymphadenectomy will effectively prolong overall survival compared to wide excision of the primary melanoma alone.2

It was prolongation of overall survival, and not disease-specific survival as the authors state.1

The MSLT-1 final report3 is an example of selective reporting bias, and failed to prove its primary outcome. The conclusions based on the post-hoc analysis are unreliable, and should never be used to guide management decisions, yet the MSLT-1 trial reporting focused almost exclusively on these results.

The other claimed benefit by the authors of MSLT-1, disease-free survival, is an illusion and has been rejected on several grounds, lead-time bias being a chief one.4

Lymph node status may not be the strongest predictor of survival for patients with intermediate thickness melanoma. Indeed, combining clinicopathological features (thickness, mitotic count, ulceration,…

email