The gap isn’t closing
The nation is failing in its efforts to close the health and life expectancy gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians.
The AMA Indigenous Health Report Card 2018, launched in Brisbane on November 22, scrutinises the 10-year-old Closing the Gap Strategy and concludes that it is unravelling.
The strategy must now be rebuilt, not refreshed, said AMA President Dr Tony Bartone.
One of the strategy’s main targets was to close the life expectancy gap by 2031, but Dr Bartone said it was obvious Australia is not on track to meet that goal.
“Ten years on, progress is limited, mixed, and disappointing,” he said.
“If anything, the gap is widening as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health gains are outpaced by improvement in non-Indigenous health outcomes.
“The strategy has all but unravelled, and efforts underway now to refresh the strategy run the risk of simply perpetuating the current implementation failures.
“The strategy needs to be rebuilt from the ground up, not simply refreshed without adequate funding and commitment from all governments to a national approach.”
Political leadership and increased funding are lacking on the issue, Dr Bartone said.
A refocussing of effort and priorities is needed.
“It is time to address the myth that it is some form of special treatment to provide additional health funding to address additional health needs in the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population,” he said.
“Government spends proportionally more on the health of older Australians when compared to young Australians, simply because elderly people’s health needs are proportionally greater.
“The same principle should be applied when assessing what equitable Indigenous health spending is, relative to non-Indigenous health expenditure.”
The Australian Institute of Health and Welfare estimates that the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander burden of disease is 2.3 times greater than the non-Indigenous burden, meaning that the Indigenous population has 2.3 times the health needs of the non-Indigenous population.
This means that for every $1 spent on health care for a non-Indigenous person, $2.30 should be spent on care for an Indigenous person.
But this is not the case, Dr Bartone said. For every $1 spent by the Commonwealth on primary health care, including Medicare, for a non-Indigenous person, only 90 cents is spent on an Indigenous person – a 61 per cent shortfall.
For the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme, the gap is even greater – 63 cents for every dollar, or a 73 per cent shortfall from the equitable spend.
“Spending less per capita on those with worse health, and particularly on their primary health care services, is dysfunctional national policy,” he said.
“It leads to us spending six times more on hospital care for Indigenous Australians than we do on prevention-oriented care from GPs and other doctors.”
The Report Card outlines six areas where the Closing the Gap Strategy can be rebuilt.
These include: equitable, needs-based expenditure; implementing health and mental health plans; filling primary health care service gaps; environmental health and housing; addressing social determinants; and placing Aboriginal health in Aboriginal hands.
“We need those leaders, those health leaders in those various communities, to come together with the peak bodies, with the Aboriginal controlled community health organisations, and all the other people as stakeholders in this space to come together to work collaboratively and with common purpose,” Dr Bartone said.
“We will not close the gap until we provide equitable levels of health funding. We need our political leaders and commentators to tackle the irresponsible equating of equitable expenditure with ‘special treatment’ that has hindered efforts to secure the level of funding needed to close the health and life expectancy gap.”
National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) welcomed the release of the Report Card and joined the AMA in calling for the Closing the Gap Strategy to be rebuilt from the ground up.
NACCHO Chairwoman Donnella Mills called for the immediate adoption of the Report Card’s recommendations.
“We congratulate the AMA on their work to support closing the gap and endorse the recommendations in the Report,” she said.
“The Report highlights research which indicates the mortality gaps between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and non-Indigenous Australians are widening, not narrowing.
“Urgent and systematic action is needed to reverse these failures and to have any prospect of meeting the Council of Australian Governments’ goal to Close the Gap in life expectancy by 2031.”
The AMA 2018 Indigenous Health Report Card is on the AMA website.